Allgemeines > Bücher, Filme, Publikationen

historische filme im aktuellen fernsehprogramm

<< < (9/19) > >>

Axebreaker:
Your probely right ;) ,just start a new thread on the topic. :)

Angrist:
Well I could do that but I wouldn´t know what to discute about, or better said, why

because your point of view is, that the overall impressions counts more than a lot of mistakes, and the Grenadier and I think that you have to look at the details and then decide whether they ruin the whole movie

between these ópinions there isn´t much to argue, because every mistake we find, won´t change your opinion of the \"overall impression\"

So because of this I won´t open a thread (also i wouldn´t know how to call the thread ;) private argument of angrist, axebreaker and grenadier christian  :D )

But of course feel free to open a thread if you wan´t do talk about sth

Considering the shipfights in the colosseum. Grenadier is right when he says that sth never happened. There were \"pools\" for that sort of entertainment which were used for sth (two of these were found by archaelogists but this knowledge ist 4 years old, maybe they found more since then), but ship fighting was far less popular then the gladiator games.

It wasn´t done in the collosseum, because of the obvios reason, that there was a wooden arenafloor with 3-5 floors below ground level which would have been flooded then

Grenadier Christian:

--- Zitat von: \'Angrist\',index.php?page=Thread&postID=11841#post11841 ---Considering the shipfights in the colosseum. Grenadier is wright when he says that sth never happened. There were \"pools\" for that sort of entertainment which were used for sth (two of these were found by archaelogists but this knowledge ist 4 years old, maybe they found more since then), but ship fighting was far less popular then the gladiator games.

It wasn´t done in the collosseum, becaus of the obvios reason, that there was a wooden arenafloor with 3-5 floors below ground level which would have been flooded then
--- Ende Zitat ---
Well, according to Sueton, it was done twice, once during the reign of Titus for the opening celebrations of the amphitheatrum flavium, and once again under his successor (and brother) Domitianus. The underground section was added during the reign of Domitianus, not during construction in the 70s.

So you can´t say it DIDN´T happen, but the idea that the colosseum was regularly flooded to stage naumachiae is a misconception. Apart from the technical difficulties, battles on a lake could be far more impressive, and you actually had the option of manoeuvering (somehow).

Grenadier Christian:
Argh, Doppelpost. Wenn das ein Mod liest, bitte diesen hier löschen. Danke!

Mehrunes:
War nicht die Schlacht am Angrivarierwall Vorbild für die Eröffnungsszene von Gladiator, außer dass man sie halt in die Markomannenkriege transferiert hat?

Navigation

[0] Themen-Index

[#] Nächste Seite

[*] Vorherige Sete